cphil_evolution

 

THE PROBLEM OF EVOLUTION

by Ray Shelton

 

I.  INTRODUCTION

The problem of evolution is a subdivision of the problem of change and the problem of the one and the many, which has been dealt with previously. The word “evolution” is from the Latin e (“out”) and volvere (“to roll”), and the concept has been defined in many ways in the history of philosophy. In general the concept of evolution has been taken to mean development, growth, progress, variation, transformation. But since the middle of nineteenth century the meaning of the word “evolution” has been determined by Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution.

 

TABLE OF CONTENTS

 

II.  HISTORY

A.  ANCIENT THEORIES

1.  Anaximander

2.  Heraclitus

3.  Empedocles

4.  Democritus

5.  Epicureans

6.  Plato

7.  Aristotle

8.  Stoicism

9.  Plotinus and Neoplatonism

10.  Augustine

11.  Medieval Scholasticism


B.  MODERN THEORIES
As modern science began with a revolt in astronomy against AristotelianPtolemaic view of the universe by Copernicus, Kepler, and Galileo and in physics against Aristotelian physics by Galileo and Isaac Newton, in the nineteenth century modern science continued this revolt against Aristotle in biology and geology.

1.  Geology

2.  Uniformitarism

3.  Lyell

4.  Lamarck

5.  Darwin

6.  Reactions to Darwin

7.  Spencer

8.  Haeckel

9.  Morgan

10.  Alexander

11.  Bergson


III.  EVALUATION

A.  Variation and Selection

B.  Genetic Mutations

1.  Mutations are Random, not Directed

2.  Mutations are Very, Very Rare

3.  Good Mutations are Very, Very Rare


C.  Similaries and Differences


D.  Uniformitarianism

1.  Igneous Rocks and Volcanism

2.  Earth Movement and Orogeny

3.  Continental Ice Sheets

4.  Sedimentation


E.  Geologic Column

F.  Uniformitarianism and the Laws of Thermodynamics

G.  Radioactive Clock

H.  Age of the Earth – Helium Dating

I.  Continental Drift